Car Dolly vs Auto Transport Trailer vs Professional Car Shipping

Car dolly vs car trailer vs professional car shipping comparison by NexGen Auto Transport
Table of Contents

Short answer: A tow dolly is the cheapest way to move a car yourself, but it only suits lighter front-wheel-drive cars. An auto transport trailer carries any drivetrain with all four wheels off the road, but it needs a heavier tow vehicle. Professional car shipping costs more than a rental fee alone, but it means no towing, no tow vehicle and no extra days on the road. Get a free shipping quote to compare.

Calculate Your Car Shipping Cost

1Where is it going?
2What are you shipping?
3How and when?

When you need to move a car to a new city, you have three common choices: tow it on a dolly, tow it on a full car trailer, or pay a company to ship it. Each one fits a different car, a different tow vehicle and a different distance. This guide explains how each option works, what it really costs and which one fits your move.

Car Dolly vs Car Trailer vs Car Shipping at a Glance

Tow dollyAuto transport trailerProfessional shipping
How the car ridesFront wheels up, rear wheels on the roadAll four wheels on the trailerOn a carrier truck
DrivetrainsFront-wheel drive; others need the driveshaft disconnectedAny drivetrainAny drivetrain
U-Haul empty weight740 lbs2,210 lbsNot applicable
U-Haul maximum load4,080 lbs5,290 lbsNot applicable
Tow vehicleMust outweigh the towed car by at least 750 lbsCurb weight must exceed the loaded trailerNone needed
Wear on your carRear tires and parts turn the whole tripNoneNone
Your effortLoad, strap and towLoad, strap and towHand over the keys

U-Haul figures from its auto transport page, towing guide and tow dolly vs auto transport comparison. Other rental companies’ equipment can differ.

Option 1: Tow Dolly

A tow dolly is a small two-wheel trailer. You drive your car’s front wheels onto it and strap them down, and the rear wheels roll on the road behind you. It is the lightest and usually the least expensive rental, and it is easy to store and return.

Which cars can go on a tow dolly?

U-Haul says its tow dolly is designed for lighter front-wheel-drive cars. Rear-wheel, all-wheel and four-wheel drive vehicles can only go on one if the driveshaft is disconnected from the transmission and secured, which is mechanic work most people do not want to do. Towing an all-wheel-drive car with two wheels on the road without that step can damage the drivetrain.

Weight rules

U-Haul’s dolly weighs 740 lbs empty and is rated for a maximum load of 4,080 lbs. U-Haul also requires the tow vehicle to weigh at least 750 lbs more than the car being towed. A small crossover towing a midsize sedan may not pass that test.

Pros and cons

ProsCons
Lowest rental cost of the threeWorks best only for front-wheel-drive cars
Light, so more vehicles can pull itRear tires, wheel bearings and brakes of the towed car wear during the trip
Easy to maneuver and parkBacking up is very difficult, because the dolly pivots
Good for short local movesOdometer may add miles on some cars, depending on how the car records distance

Option 2: Auto Transport Trailer

A car trailer, which U-Haul calls an auto transport, carries the whole car on a two-axle deck. Nothing touches the road, so drivetrain does not matter and your car does not wear during the trip. For full specifications and a cost breakdown, see our guide to the U-Haul auto transport trailer vs car shipping.

Weight rules

The trailer weighs 2,210 lbs empty, carries up to 5,290 lbs, and the combined weight can reach 7,500 lbs. U-Haul requires your tow vehicle’s curb weight to exceed the loaded trailer, so most people need a full-size pickup, a large SUV or a U-Haul moving truck. U-Haul’s maximum recommended speed is 55 mph.

Pros and cons

ProsCons
Works for any drivetrain, including AWD and 4×4Needs a heavy tow vehicle
No wear on the towed carHeavier load means more fuel and slower travel
Easier to back up than a dollyCosts more to rent than a dolly
Safer for longer trips than a dollyStill limited to 55 mph

Want to skip towing? Compare a shipping quote

Call Now: + (832) 886-1321 Get a Free Quote

Option 3: Professional Car Shipping

With car shipping, a licensed carrier picks up your car and hauls it on a multi-car truck to your new address. You do not need a tow vehicle, a hitch or towing experience, and you can fly or drive your other car while it travels.

Pricing depends mostly on distance and season. As a guide, a sedan shipped about 1,000 to 1,500 miles on an open carrier usually costs around $900 to $1,500. Our route guides show estimates for common moves, such as New York to Florida and shipping a car to Texas.

Which Option Should You Choose?

Your situationBest option
Front-wheel-drive car, short local move, tow vehicle that outweighs it by 750+ lbsTow dolly
All-wheel or rear-wheel drive car, heavy pickup or moving truck, medium-length moveAuto transport trailer
Long or cross-country moveProfessional shipping
You are flying to your new homeProfessional shipping
Your vehicle cannot meet the rental’s weight rulesProfessional shipping
Valuable, classic or brand-new carEnclosed shipping
Car that does not runProfessional shipping with a winch. See shipping a car that does not run

How to Load a Car on a Tow Dolly or Trailer Safely

If you decide to tow, take your time at the rental lot. U-Haul’s instructions call for two people to load, the tow vehicle in park with the parking brake on, and both front tires secured with the supplied ratchet straps. A few habits make the trip much safer:

  1. Load on flat, level ground, never on a slope.
  2. Drive the car on slowly and center it, with a second person guiding you.
  3. Strap both front tires and check that each strap is tight and the ratchets are locked.
  4. On a car trailer, set the towed car’s parking brake, raise the side fender and latch the ramps before you drive.
  5. Leave the towed car empty. U-Haul says not to load extra cargo into it.
  6. Check every light on the trailer and tow vehicle before you leave.
  7. Re-check the straps after the first few miles and at every fuel stop.

Driving tips while towing

  • Keep to U-Haul’s posted maximum speed for its equipment, which is 55 mph for the auto transport trailer.
  • Leave much more following distance than usual, because stopping takes longer.
  • Plan fuel stops at larger stations with pull-through lanes.
  • Avoid reversing with a tow dolly. If you must turn around, find a lot you can drive straight through.
  • In strong crosswinds or heavy rain, slow down further or wait it out.

Hidden Costs of Towing It Yourself

Rental fees are easy to compare, but they are not the whole cost of towing a car across the country. Before you decide, add up:

  • Extra fuel for pulling the extra weight.
  • Extra hotel nights, because towing equipment is limited to slower speeds.
  • Meals and time off work for the extra days.
  • A hitch or wiring installation if your vehicle does not have one.
  • Tire and brake wear on your car if you use a dolly.
  • Damage coverage on the rental.

For more ways to compare, read the cheapest way to ship a car and the cheapest way to tow a car long distance.

Related guides: Moving house too? Find out whether your moving company can ship your car.

Why Book With NexGen Auto Transport?

NexGen Auto Transport LLC is a licensed auto transport broker (FMCSA MC 1482694, USDOT 3969190) based in Stafford, Texas. We match your car with a vetted carrier, there is no upfront payment and no cancellation fee, and the carrier’s cargo insurance covers your car while it is on the truck. Multi-car moves, students and military members can save up to 20%.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a tow dolly or car trailer better for a long trip?

A car trailer is usually better for long trips, because the towed car’s wheels stay off the road and it is easier to control. A tow dolly is best for short, local moves with a front-wheel-drive car.

Can you tow an all-wheel-drive car on a tow dolly?

Not without extra work. U-Haul says rear-wheel, all-wheel and four-wheel drive vehicles need the driveshaft disconnected and secured before going on a tow dolly. A full car trailer avoids that problem.

How much weight can a U-Haul tow dolly carry?

U-Haul lists a maximum load of 4,080 lbs for its tow dolly, and the tow vehicle must weigh at least 750 lbs more than the car being towed.

Is it cheaper to tow a car or ship it?

Towing is usually cheaper for short trips if you already have a suitable vehicle. For long moves, shipping often costs about the same once fuel, hotels and extra days are included.

Does towing a car on a dolly add miles to it?

The rear wheels turn for the whole trip, so tires, bearings and brakes wear. Whether the odometer records the miles depends on the car, so check your owner’s manual before you tow.

Get your car shipping quote in minutes

Call Now: + (832) 886-1321 Get a Free Quote

About the authors

This guide was written and reviewed by the NexGen Auto Transport team in Stafford, Texas. Since 2021 we have arranged transport for more than 150,000 vehicles nationwide (FMCSA MC 1482694, USDOT 3969190). Prices and transit times reflect our current rates. Read our editorial policy.

Share this guide: Facebook · X · LinkedIn · Email

Share on:

Scroll to Top
Call Now Free Quote